Psychopathic Disorders and Judges Sentencing: Can Neurosciences Change This Aggravating Factor in a Mitigating Factor?
References:
[1] Matt Logan et Robert D. Hare, «La psychopathie criminelle:
introduction à l'égard des policiers», (2010), p. 2
[2] Craig S. Neumann et Robert D. HARE, «Psychopathic traits in a large
community sample: Links to violence, alcohol use, and intelligence»,
(2008) 76, p. 893-900
[3] Gina M. Vincent et Stephen D. Hart, «Legal uses and assessment of
psychopathy», (2012)
[4] Robert James R. Blair, «Applying a cognitive neuroscience perspective
to the disorder of psychopathy», (2005) 17 Development and
Psychopathology
[5] Henry Werlinder, Psychopathy : a history of the concepts : analysis of
the origin and development of a family of concepts in psychopathology,
Stockholm, Uppsala Universitet, 1978
[6] Jennifer Cox, David S. Dematteo et Elizabeth E. Foster, «The effect of
the Psychopathy Checklist--Revised in capital cases: mock jurors'
responses to the label of psychopathy», (2010) 28 Behavior Science and
the Law; Jenny Laurell et Anna Maria Daderman, «Psychopathy (PCLR)
in a forensic psychiatric sample of homicide offenders: some
reliability issues», (2007) 30International journal of law and psychiatry
[7] Julien-Daniel Guelfi et American Psychiatric Association, DSM-IV-TR:
Manuel statistique et diagnostique des troubles mentaux, 4e éd., texte
rév, Paris, Masson, 2003, p. 808
[8] Organisation Mondiale de la Santé, Classification internationale des
maladies, Paris, Masson, 1994
[9] Aharon Barak, «The Judge in a Democracy», (2008) 56 The American
Journal of Comparative Law
[10] Ivan Zinger et A. E Forth, «Psychopathy and Canadian Criminal
Proceedings: The Potential for Human Rights Abuses», (1998) 40
Canadian Journal of Criminology
[11] Stephen Porter, Leanne ten Brinke et Kevin Wilson, «Crime profiles and
conditional release performance of psychopathic and non psychopathic
sexual offenders», (2009) 14 Legal and Criminological Psychology
[12] Erika Braithwaite, Examining the incremental validity of psychopathy
versus antisocial personnality disorder in understanding patterns of
criminal behavior, Département de Psychologie, Université de Montreal,
2010
[13] Laurent F. Friedman et Simon N. Verdun-Jones, «Blaming the Parts
Instead of the Person: understanding and Applying Neurobiological
Factors Associated with Psychopathy», (2010) 52 Canadian Journal of
Criminology and Criminal Justice
[14] Canadian criminal code, art. 753
[15] L. F. Friedman et S. N. Verdun-Jones, préc., note 18
[16] R. v. W.T.W., (1997) B.C.J. No. 3157 (BCPC) (QL)
[17] Jenny Laurell et Anna M. Daderman, «Recidivism is related to
psychopathy (PCL-R) in a group of men convicted of homicide», (2005)
28International journal of law and psychiatry
[18] Howard E. Barbaree, «Psychopathy, treatment behavior, and recidivism:
an extended follow-up of Seto and Barbaree», (2005) 20 Journal of
Interpersonal Violence
[19] L. F. Friedman et S. N. Verdun-Jones, préc., note 18
[20] Richard Dawkins, «Straf is wetenschappelijk achterhaald», (2006) NRCHandelsblad
[21] G. B. Palermo, «Psychopathy: Early and Recent Clinical Observations
and the Law», (2011) 55 International Journal of Offender Therapy and
Comparative Criminology
[22] Carl B. Gacono, James L. Loving, F. Barton Evans et Michael T. Jumes,
«The Psychopathy Checklist-Revised: PCL-R Testimony and Forensic
Practice», (2002) 2 Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice
[23] Lisa G. Aspinwall, Teneille R. Brown et James Tabery, «The Double-
Edged Sword: Does Biomechanism Increase or Decrease Judges'
Sentencing of Psychopaths?», (2012) 337 Science
[24] Adam Lamparello, «Using Cognitive Neuroscience to predict Future
Dangerousness», (2011) 42 Columbia Human rights law review
[25] Kimberly D. Phillips, «Empathy for psychopaths: Using fMRI Brains
Scans to Plea for Leniency in Death Penaltys Cases», (2013) 37 Law and
Psychology Review
[26] Adrian Raine, «From Genes to Brain to Antisocial Behavior», (2008)
17Current Directions in Psychological Science
[27] Robert James Blair, K. S. Pershardt, S. Budhani, D. G. Mitchell etD. S.
Pine, «The development of psychopathy», (2006) 47 Journal of Child
Psychology and Psychiatry
[28] R. J. R. Blair, D. G. V. Mitchell, K. S. Peschardt, E. Colledge, R. A.
Leonard, J. H. Shine, L. K. Murray et D. I. Perrett, «Reduced sensitivity
to others’ fearful expressions in psychopathic individuals», (2004)
37Personality and Individual Differences.
[29] Robert James R. Blair, «The emergence of psychopathy: implications for
the neuropsychological approach to developmental disorders», (2006)
101Cognition.
[30] Robert James R. BLAIR, «The Cognitive Neuroscience of Psychopathy
and Implications for Judgments of Responsibility», (2008) 1 Neuroethics
[31] David De Matteo et John F. Edens, «The role and relevance of the
Psychopathy Checklist-Revised in Court: A case law survey of U.S.
Courts (1991-2004)», (2006) 12(2) Psychology, Public Policy, and Law
[32] Sarah Becker, A glimpse into the future? The Current, Potential, and
Appropriate Role of Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI)
Evidence as a predictor of Dangerousness in the American Criminal
Sentencing Context, Faculty of law, University of Toronto, 2013
[33] L.G. Aspinwall, T.R. Brown et J. Tabery, préc., note 31
[34] Hyman GROSS, A Theory of criminal justice, New York, Oxford Press
University, 1979
[35] Judith G. Edersheim, Rebecca Weintraub Brendel et Bruce H. Price,
«Neuroimaging, Diminished Capacity and Mitigation», dans
Neuroimaging in Forensic Psychiatry: From the Clinic to the
courtroom, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2012,
[36] L.G. Aspinwall, T.R. Brown et J. Tabery, préc., note 31
[37] Brett Walker, «When the Facts and the Law Are Against You, Argue the
Genes? : A pragmatic Analysis of Genotyping Mitigation Defendants in
Death Penalty Cases», (2013) 90 Washington University Law Review
[38] People v. Morgan (1999) 719 N.E.2d 681 (III.1999).
[39] Rogers v. State (2001) 783 So 2d 980 (Fla.2001).
[40] Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, art. 7
[41] Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, art. 12
[42] R. v. Bishop, 1993 ABCA 274