Open Science Research Excellence

Open Science Index

Commenced in January 2007 Frequency: Monthly Edition: International Publications Count: 31181

Select areas to restrict search in scientific publication database:
Review and Classification of the Indicators and Trends Used in Bridge Performance Modeling
Bridges, as an essential part of road infrastructures, are affected by various deterioration mechanisms over time due to the changes in their performance. As changes in performance can have many negative impacts on society, it is essential to be able to evaluate and measure the performance of bridges throughout their life. This evaluation includes the development or the choice of the appropriate performance indicators, which, in turn, are measured based on the selection of appropriate models for the existing deterioration mechanism. The purpose of this article is a statistical study of indicators and deterioration mechanisms of bridges in order to discover further research capacities in bridges performance assessment. For this purpose, some of the most common indicators of bridge performance, including reliability, risk, vulnerability, robustness, and resilience, were selected. The researches performed on each index based on the desired deterioration mechanisms and hazards were comprehensively reviewed. In addition, the formulation of the indicators and their relationship with each other were studied. The research conducted on the mentioned indicators were classified from the point of view of deterministic or probabilistic method, the level of study (element level, object level, etc.), and the type of hazard and the deterioration mechanism of interest. For each of the indicators, a number of challenges and recommendations were presented according to the review of previous studies.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI):


[1] ASCE. 2013. Report card for America’s infrastructure. Reston, VA, 〈http://www.〉.
[2] Hendawi, S. and Frangopol, D.M. 1994. System reliability and redundancy in structural design and evaluation. Structural Safety, 16(1-2):47-71.
[3] Czarnecki, A.A. and Nowak. A.S. 2007. Reliability-based evaluation of steel girder bridges. In Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Bridge Engineering, 160, Issue BE1: 9–15.
[4] Ditlevsen, O. and Bjerager, P. 1986. Methods of structural systems reliability. Structural Safety, 3(3): 195-229
[5] Galambos, T. V. 1990. Systems reliability and structural design. Structural Safety, 7(2-4): 101-108.
[6] Rashedi, M.R. and Moses, F. 1988. Identification of failure modes in system reliability. Journal of Structural Engineering, 114(2): 292-313.
[7] Tang, K. and Melchers, R.E. 1988. Incremental formulation for structural reliability analysis. Civil Engineering Systems, 5(3): 153-158.
[8] Thoft-Christensen, P. and Murotsu, Y. 1986. Application of Structural Systems Reliability Theory. , Springer, Berlin.
[9] Vu, K. and Stewart, M.G. 2000. Structural reliability of concrete bridges including improved chloride-induced corrosion models. Structural Safety, 22(4): 313-333.
[10] Huang, C., El Hami, A., and Radi, B. 2017. Overview of structural reliability analysis methods—Part I: local reliability methods. Incert. Fiabil. Syst. Multiphys, 17: 1-10.
[11] Huang, C., El Hami, A., and Radi, B. 2016. Overview of structural reliability analysis methods—Part II: sampling methods. ISTE OpenScience: London, UK.
[12] Huang, C., El Hami, A., and Radi, B. 2016. Overview of structural reliability analysis methods—Part III: global reliability methods. ISTE OpenScience: London, UK.
[13] Liu, W. D., Neuenhoffer, A., Ghosn, M., and Moses, F. 2001. Redundancy in highway bridge substructures (No. Project D12-47 FY'97).
[14] Ghosn, M., and Moses, F. 1998. Redundancy in highway bridge superstructures (Vol. 406). Transportation Research Board.
[15] Okasha, N.M. and Frangopol, D.M. 2010b. Novel approach for multi-criteria optimization of life-cycle preventive and essential maintenance of deteriorating structures. Journal of Structural Engineering, 136(8): 1009-1022.
[16] Okasha, N.M. and Frangopol, D.M. 2010d. Time-variant redundancy of structural systems. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 6(1-2): 279-301
[17] Yang, S., Frangopol, D.M., and Neves, L.C. 2004. Service life prediction of structural systems using lifetime functions with emphasis on bridges. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 86(1): 39-51.
[18] Enright, M.P. and Frangopol, D.M. 1999a. Condition prediction of deteriorating concrete bridges. Journal of Structural Engineering, 125(10): 1118-1125.
[19] Enright, M.P. and Frangopol, D.M. 1999b. Reliability-based condition assessment of deteriorating concrete bridges considering load redistribution. Structural Safety, 21(2): 159-195.
[20] Enright, M.P. and Frangopol, D.M. 2000. RELTSYS: A computer program for life prediction of deteriorating system. Structural Engineering and Mechanics, 9(6): 557-568
[21] Estes, A. C., and Frangopol, D. M. 1998. RELSYS: a computer program for structural system reliability. Structural engineering and mechanics, 6(8): 901-919.
[22] Tabsh, S. W. and Nowak, A. S. 1991. Reliability of highway girder bridges. Journal of structural engineering, 117(8): 2372–2388.
[23] Val, D. V. and Melchers, R. E. 1997. Reliability of deteriorating RC slab bridges. Journal of structural engineering, 123(12): 1638–1644.
[24] Stewart, M. G. and Rosowsky, D. V. 1998. Structural safety and serviceability of concrete bridges subject to corrosion. Journal of Infrastructure systems, 4(4): 146–155.
[25] Vu, K. A. T. and Stewart, M. G. 2000. Structural reliability of concrete bridges including improved chloride-induced corrosion models. Structural safety, 22(4):313–333.
[26] Kong, J. S. and Frangopol, D. M. 2003. Life-cycle reliability-based maintenance cost optimization of deteriorating structures with emphasis on bridges. Journal of Structural Engineering, 129(6): 818–828.
[27] Johnson, P. A. and Ayyub, B. M. 1992. Assessing time-variant bridge reliability due to pier scour. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering. 118(6): 887–903.
[28] Muzzammil, M., Siddiqui, N. A., and Siddiqui, A. F. 2008. Reliability considerations in bridge pier scouring. Structural Engineering and Mechanics. 28 (1): 1–18
[29] Choi, E., DesRoches, R., and Nielson, B. 2004. Seismic fragility of typical bridges in moderate seismic zones. Engineering Structures, 26(2): 187–199.
[30] Duenas-Osorio, L., and Padgett, J. E. 2011. Seismic reliability assessment of bridges with user-defined system failure events. Journal of engineering mechanics, 137(10): 680–690.
[31] Padgett, J. E., Spiller, A., and Arnold, C. 2012. Statistical analysis of coastal bridge vulnerability based on empirical evidence from Hurricane Katrina. Structure and infrastructure engineering, 8(6):595–605.
[32] Ataei, N., and Padgett, J. E. 2012. Probabilistic modeling of bridge deck unseating during Hurricane events. Journal of Bridge Engineering, 18(4): 275-286.
[33] Yanweerasak, T., Pansuk, W., Akiyama, M., and Frangopol, D. M. 2018. Life-cycle reliability assessment of reinforced concrete bridges under multiple hazards. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 14(7), 1011-1024.
[34] Ghosn, M., Frangopol, D. M., McAllister, T. P., Shah, M., Diniz, S. M. C., Ellingwood, B. R., and Zhao, X. L. 2016. Reliability-based performance indicators for structural members. Journal of Structural Engineering, 142(9): F4016002.
[35] Biondini, F., and Frangopol, D. M. (2016). Life-cycle performance of deteriorating structural systems under uncertainty. Journal of Structural Engineering, 142(9), F4016001.
[36] Zhu, B., and Frangopol, D. M. 2012. Reliability, redudancy and risk as performance indicators of structural systems during their life-cycle. Engineering Structures, 41: 34–49.
[37] Cesare, M., Santamarina, J. C., Turkstra, C. J., and Vanmarcke, E. 1993. Risk-based bridge management. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 119(5): 742-750.
[38] Stein, S.M., Young, G.K., Trent, R.E., and Pearson, D.R. 1999. Prioritizing scour vulnerable bridges using risk. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 5(3): 95-101.
[39] Adey, B., Hajdin, R. and Bruhwiler, E. 2003. Supply and demand system approach to development of bridge management strategies. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 9(3): 117-131.
[40] Lounis, Z. 2004. Risk-based maintenance optimization of bridge structures. In 2nd International Colloquium on Advanced Structural Reliability Analysis Network (ASRANet), 1-9.
[41] Stein, S. and Sedmera, K. 2006. Risk-based management guidelines for scour at bridges with unknown foundations. Transportation Research Board of the National Academies.
[42] Ang, A. H–S. 2011. Life-cycle considerations in risk-informed decisions for design of civil infrastructures. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 7(1-2):3-9.
[43] Decò A. and Frangopol, D.M. 2011. Risk assessment of highway bridges under multiple hazards. Journal of Risk Research, 14(9): 1057-1089.
[44] Saydam, D., Frangopol, D.M, and Dong, Y. 2013b. Assessment of Risk using Bridge Element Condition Ratings, Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 19(3): 252-265.
[45] Ghosh, J., and Padgett, J. E. 2011. Probabilistic seismic loss assessment of aging bridges using a component-level cost estimation approach. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 40(15): 1743-1761.
[46] Alipour, A., and Shafei, B. 2015. Assessment of post-earthquake losses in a network of aging bridges. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 22(2):04015023.
[47] Zanini, M. A., Faleschini, F., and Pellegrino, C. 2016b. Seismic loss assessment of deteriorating bridge networks, in 8th International Conference on Bridge Maintenance, Safety and Management IABMAS2016 (Foz do Iguacu), 26–30 June 2016.
[48] Saydam, D., and Frangopol, D. M. 2011. Time-dependent performance indicators of damaged bridge superstructures. Engineering Structures, 33(9): 2458–2471.
[49] Starossek, U., and Haberland, M. 2011. Approaches to measures of structural robustness. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 7(7-8): 625-631.
[50] Anitori, G., Casas, J. R., and Ghosn, M. 2013. Redundancy and robustness in the design and evaluation of bridges: European and North American perspectives. Journal of Bridge Engineering, 18(12):1241–1251.
[51] Cavaco, E., Casas, J. R., Neves, L., and Huespe, A. 2013. Robustness of corroded reinforced concrete structures. A structural performance approach. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 9(1): 42-58.
[52] Baker, J.W., Schubert, M., and Faber, M. 2008. On the assessment of robustness. Structural Safety, 30(3): 253–267.
[53] Frangopol, D. M., and Curley, J. P. 1987. Effects of damage and redundancy on structural reliability. Journal of structural engineering, 113(7): 1533-1549.
[54] Maes, M. A., Fritzsons, K. E., and Glowienka, S. 2006. Structural robustness in the light of risk and consequence analysis. Structural engineering international, 16(2): 101-107.
[55] Ghosn, M., and Moses, F. 1998. Redundancy in Highway Bridge Superstructures (Vol. 406). Transportation Research Board.
[56] Liu, W. D., Ghosn, M., Moses, F., and Neuenhoffer, A. 2000. Redundancy in Highway Bridge Substructures, NCHRP Report 458, Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.
[57] Sorensen, J. D., Rizzuto, E., Narasimhan, H., and Faber, M. H. 2012. Robustness: theoretical framework. Structural engineering international, 22(1): 66-72.
[58] Biondini, F., and Frangopol, D. M. 2014. Time-variant performance indicators for concrete bridges exposed to corrosion. In 9th Austroads Bridge Conference (pp. 1-13). Australian Road Research Board (ARRB).
[59] Cavaco, E., Neves, L., and Casas, J. R. 2017. Reliability-based approach to the robustness of corroded RC structures. Structural Concrete, 18(2): 316-325.
[60] Cavaco, E., Neves, L., and Casas, J. R. 2018. On the robustness to corrosion in the life-cycle assessment of an existing reinforced concrete bridge. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 14(2): 137-150.
[61] Wisniewski, D., Casas, J. R., and Ghosn, M. 2006. Load capacity evaluation of existing railway bridges based on robustness quantification. Structural Engineering International, 16(2): 161-166.
[62] Stochino, F., Bedon, C., Sagaseta, J., and Honfi, D. 2019. Robustness and Resilience of Structures under Extreme Loads. Advances in Civil Engineering, 2019.
[63] Lind, N. C. 1995. A measure of vulnerability and damage tolerance. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 48(1), 1-6.
[64] Morbin, R., Zanini, M. A., Pellegrino, C., Zhang, H., and Modena, C. 2015. A probabilistic strategy for seismic assessment and FRP retrofitting of existing bridges. Bulletin of earthquake Engineering, 13(8): 2411-2428.
[65] Zampieri, P., Zanini, M. A., and Faleschini, F. 2016. Derivation of analytical seismic fragility functions for common masonry bridge types: methodology and application to real cases. Engineering failure analysis, 68: 275-291.
[66] Choe, D., Gardoni, P., Rosowsky, D., and Haukaas, T. 2009. Seismic fragility estimates for reinforced concrete bridges subject to corrosion. Structural Safety, 31(4): 275-283.
[67] Ghosh, J., and Padgett, J. E. 2010. Aging considerations in the development of time-dependent seismic fragility curves. Journal of Structural Engineering, 136(12): 1497-1511.
[68] Simon, J., Bracci, J. M., and Gardoni, P. 2010. Seismic response and fragility of deteriorated reinforced concrete bridges. Journal of Structural Engineering, 136(10): 1273-1281.
[69] Zanini, M. A., Pellegrino, C., Morbin, R., and Modena, C. 2013. Seismic vulnerability of bridges in transport networks subjected to environmental deterioration. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 11(2): 561-579.
[70] Bruneau, M., Chang, S. E., Eguchi, R. T., Lee, G. C., O’Rourke, T. D., Reinhorn, A. M., ... and Von Winterfeldt, D. 2003. A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities. Earthquake spectra, 19(4):733-752.
[71] Renschler, C. S., Frazier, A. E., Arendt, L. A., Cimellaro, G. P., Reinhorn, A. M., and Bruneau, M. 2010. A framework for defining and measuring resilience at the community scale: The PEOPLES resilience framework (pp. 10-0006). Buffalo: MCEER.
[72] Faber, M. H. 2015, October. Codified risk informed decision making for structures. In Proceedings of the symposium on reliability of engineering systems (SRES2015). Hangzhou, China (pp. 15-17).
[73] Lounis, Z., and McAllister, T. P. 2016. Risk-based decision making for sustainable and resilient infrastructure systems. Journal of Structural Engineering, 142(9): F4016005.
[74] McDaniels, T., Chang, S., Cole, D., Mikawoz, J., and Longstaff, H. 2008. Fostering resilience to extreme events within infrastructure systems: Characterizing decision contexts for mitigation and adaptation. Global Environmental Change, 18(2): 310-318.
[75] Cimellaro, G. P., Reinhorn, A. M., and Bruneau, M. 2010. Framework for analytical quantification of disaster resilience. Engineering structures, 32(11): 3639-3649.
[76] Zobel, C. W. 2011. Representing perceived tradeoffs in defining disaster resilience. Decision Support Systems, 50(2): 394-403.
[77] Bocchini, P., Frangopol, D. M., Ummenhofer, T., and Zinke, T. 2013. Resilience and sustainability of civil infrastructure: toward a unified approach. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 20(2): 04014004.
[78] Biondini, F., Camnasio, E., and Titi, A. (2015). “Seismic resilience of concrete structures under corrosion.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn. 44(14), 2445–2466.
[79] Ellingwood, B.R. 2005. Risk-informed condition assessment of civil infrastructure: State of practice and research issues. Structure and infrastructure engineering, 1(1): 7-18.
[80] FHWA. 2015. Highway bridges by superstructure material 2015. Washington, DC, 〈 bi/no10/ma)
Vol:15 No:04 2021Vol:15 No:03 2021Vol:15 No:02 2021Vol:15 No:01 2021
Vol:14 No:12 2020Vol:14 No:11 2020Vol:14 No:10 2020Vol:14 No:09 2020Vol:14 No:08 2020Vol:14 No:07 2020Vol:14 No:06 2020Vol:14 No:05 2020Vol:14 No:04 2020Vol:14 No:03 2020Vol:14 No:02 2020Vol:14 No:01 2020
Vol:13 No:12 2019Vol:13 No:11 2019Vol:13 No:10 2019Vol:13 No:09 2019Vol:13 No:08 2019Vol:13 No:07 2019Vol:13 No:06 2019Vol:13 No:05 2019Vol:13 No:04 2019Vol:13 No:03 2019Vol:13 No:02 2019Vol:13 No:01 2019
Vol:12 No:12 2018Vol:12 No:11 2018Vol:12 No:10 2018Vol:12 No:09 2018Vol:12 No:08 2018Vol:12 No:07 2018Vol:12 No:06 2018Vol:12 No:05 2018Vol:12 No:04 2018Vol:12 No:03 2018Vol:12 No:02 2018Vol:12 No:01 2018
Vol:11 No:12 2017Vol:11 No:11 2017Vol:11 No:10 2017Vol:11 No:09 2017Vol:11 No:08 2017Vol:11 No:07 2017Vol:11 No:06 2017Vol:11 No:05 2017Vol:11 No:04 2017Vol:11 No:03 2017Vol:11 No:02 2017Vol:11 No:01 2017
Vol:10 No:12 2016Vol:10 No:11 2016Vol:10 No:10 2016Vol:10 No:09 2016Vol:10 No:08 2016Vol:10 No:07 2016Vol:10 No:06 2016Vol:10 No:05 2016Vol:10 No:04 2016Vol:10 No:03 2016Vol:10 No:02 2016Vol:10 No:01 2016
Vol:9 No:12 2015Vol:9 No:11 2015Vol:9 No:10 2015Vol:9 No:09 2015Vol:9 No:08 2015Vol:9 No:07 2015Vol:9 No:06 2015Vol:9 No:05 2015Vol:9 No:04 2015Vol:9 No:03 2015Vol:9 No:02 2015Vol:9 No:01 2015
Vol:8 No:12 2014Vol:8 No:11 2014Vol:8 No:10 2014Vol:8 No:09 2014Vol:8 No:08 2014Vol:8 No:07 2014Vol:8 No:06 2014Vol:8 No:05 2014Vol:8 No:04 2014Vol:8 No:03 2014Vol:8 No:02 2014Vol:8 No:01 2014
Vol:7 No:12 2013Vol:7 No:11 2013Vol:7 No:10 2013Vol:7 No:09 2013Vol:7 No:08 2013Vol:7 No:07 2013Vol:7 No:06 2013Vol:7 No:05 2013Vol:7 No:04 2013Vol:7 No:03 2013Vol:7 No:02 2013Vol:7 No:01 2013
Vol:6 No:12 2012Vol:6 No:11 2012Vol:6 No:10 2012Vol:6 No:09 2012Vol:6 No:08 2012Vol:6 No:07 2012Vol:6 No:06 2012Vol:6 No:05 2012Vol:6 No:04 2012Vol:6 No:03 2012Vol:6 No:02 2012Vol:6 No:01 2012
Vol:5 No:12 2011Vol:5 No:11 2011Vol:5 No:10 2011Vol:5 No:09 2011Vol:5 No:08 2011Vol:5 No:07 2011Vol:5 No:06 2011Vol:5 No:05 2011Vol:5 No:04 2011Vol:5 No:03 2011Vol:5 No:02 2011Vol:5 No:01 2011
Vol:4 No:12 2010Vol:4 No:11 2010Vol:4 No:10 2010Vol:4 No:09 2010Vol:4 No:08 2010Vol:4 No:07 2010Vol:4 No:06 2010Vol:4 No:05 2010Vol:4 No:04 2010Vol:4 No:03 2010Vol:4 No:02 2010Vol:4 No:01 2010
Vol:3 No:12 2009Vol:3 No:11 2009Vol:3 No:10 2009Vol:3 No:09 2009Vol:3 No:08 2009Vol:3 No:07 2009Vol:3 No:06 2009Vol:3 No:05 2009Vol:3 No:04 2009Vol:3 No:03 2009Vol:3 No:02 2009Vol:3 No:01 2009
Vol:2 No:12 2008Vol:2 No:11 2008Vol:2 No:10 2008Vol:2 No:09 2008Vol:2 No:08 2008Vol:2 No:07 2008Vol:2 No:06 2008Vol:2 No:05 2008Vol:2 No:04 2008Vol:2 No:03 2008Vol:2 No:02 2008Vol:2 No:01 2008
Vol:1 No:12 2007Vol:1 No:11 2007Vol:1 No:10 2007Vol:1 No:09 2007Vol:1 No:08 2007Vol:1 No:07 2007Vol:1 No:06 2007Vol:1 No:05 2007Vol:1 No:04 2007Vol:1 No:03 2007Vol:1 No:02 2007Vol:1 No:01 2007